Short answer
All are good when well made. Silicone is soft and comes in vibrating models. Glass is very smooth and easy to insert. Metal is weighted and great for temperature play. Choose based on the feel you want.
Read the full guideBest butt plugs for beginners: silicone, glass and vibratingNew to butt plugs? Learn which size, shape and material to start with, how to use one safely, and our beginner picks in silicone, glass, metal and vibrating. Updated November 20, 2026 · All questions