Black FridayCyber Monday just got a whole lot... longer 😏Up to 25% OFF sitewide!PROMO CODE: BLACKFRI25 AUTO-APPLIED

Your bag

We're sorry, this product is no longer in stock

But here are some similar items we know you will love just as much, if not more.

  1. Learn
  2. Knowledge Base

Guides · 4 min read

Best butt plugs for beginners: silicone, glass and vibrating

Key takeaways

  • Always choose a plug with a flared base. Anything without one is not safe for anal use.
  • Start small, around 1 inch in diameter, and size up gradually.
  • Silicone is soft and forgiving; glass and metal are firm, smooth and easy to clean.
  • Use plenty of thick lube, and never use numbing products.
  • Relaxation is the key to comfort; go slowly and stop if anything hurts.

The best beginner butt plug is small, about 1 inch wide, and tapered for easy insertion. It needs a narrow neck and a flared base so it can't slip inside. Booty Sparks Black Rose, at 2 inches insertable and 1 inch wide, is a great first metal plug. Glas Rosebud is a smooth glass option. Lovense Hush 2 is our pick for a vibrating, app-controlled plug.

Butt plugs are one of the best ways to start exploring anal play. They're simpler than most toys: you insert one, it stays in place, and you enjoy the feeling of fullness during solo play, foreplay or sex. Many people love how a plug intensifies other sensations. The right first plug makes all the difference. Here's what to look for and our beginner picks. For the basics of comfort and safety, start with anal play for beginners.

What makes a butt plug safe?

Every anal toy must have a flared base, a wide stopper that sits outside the body. The rectum can draw objects inward, so a toy without a base can become stuck and may need medical removal. A plug also needs a narrow neck between the bulb and the base. The sphincter closes around the neck, holding the plug comfortably in place.

What size should a beginner start with?

  • Diameter: about 1 inch at the widest point is a comfortable start for most people.
  • Insertable length: 2 to 3 inches is plenty. Longer isn't better at first.
  • Shape: a tapered tip makes insertion easier; a gradual widening is gentler than a sudden bulge.

Once you're comfortable, you can size up gradually. Our butt plug size guide explains how.

Silicone, glass or metal?

MaterialFeelLubeWhy choose it
SiliconeSoft, slightly flexibleWater-based onlyComfortable, warm quickly, available with vibration
GlassFirm, very smoothAny lubeEasy to insert, non-porous, can be warmed or cooled
Metal (aluminum, steel)Firm, weightedAny lubePleasant weight, temperature play, easy to clean

All three are non-porous and body-safe when made well. Avoid jelly or rubber plugs, which are porous and hard to clean.

The best butt plugs for beginners

Booty Sparks Black Rose (small): best first metal plug

The Booty Sparks Black Rose Small is 3 inches long in total, with 2 inches insertable and a 1-inch diameter, a textbook beginner size. It's made of lightweight, nickel-free aluminum alloy with a slim shaft that keeps it in place, and a decorative black rose base. Metal is non-porous, cleans easily and responds to temperature, so you can warm it in water before use.

Glas 5" Rosebud: best glass plug

The Glas 5-inch Rosebud Glass Butt Plug is translucent pink glass with a tapered tip for easy insertion and a rose-shaped base. Glass is extremely smooth, so it glides in easily with lube, and it's non-porous and simple to clean. Check the product page for the bulb diameter to make sure it suits your comfort level.

Lovense Hush 2: best vibrating plug

The Lovense Hush 2 is a 100% silicone vibrating plug controlled from the Lovense Remote app, by you or by a partner from anywhere. Its neck is designed to stay put, spirals on the neck trap lube near the entrance so removal is easy after long sessions, and the flared base is comfortable to sit on but wide enough for safety. It's nearly silent once inserted. It comes in more than one size, so check the diameter and choose the smaller option if you're new.

How do you use a butt plug for the first time?

  1. Relax and get aroused first. Arousal helps the body relax. Try external touch around the anus before inserting anything.
  2. Use plenty of lube on the plug and the anus, and reapply. See our guide to the best lube for anal.
  3. Go slowly. Press the tip gently against the opening and breathe out as you insert, pushing out slightly as if bearing down. This relaxes the sphincter.
  4. Let your body adjust at the widest point before the plug settles onto its neck.
  5. Start with short sessions of 10 to 20 minutes, and build up gradually.
  6. Remove it slowly, while relaxed, with more lube if needed.

What should it feel like?

A sense of fullness is normal, and many people find it very pleasurable, especially during other stimulation or sex. Discomfort at the widest point is common at first and fades as you relax. Sharp pain is a signal to stop. Never use numbing creams or lubes: they hide the pain that tells you to slow down.

Can you wear a butt plug during sex?

Yes. Many people enjoy the extra fullness during vaginal sex or oral sex, or while using a vibrator. A vibrating plug like the Hush 2 adds sensation for both partners. Start with a small plug, as it can feel much tighter during penetration.

How do you clean a butt plug?

Wash it straight after use with warm water and mild unscented soap or a toy cleaner. Glass and metal plugs can also be boiled or washed in the top rack of a dishwasher if the maker says so. Never boil electronic toys. Dry fully before storing. Never move a toy from anal to vaginal use without washing it first, or putting on a fresh condom. Our cleaning guide has more.

When should you avoid anal play?

Skip it if you have hemorrhoids that are flaring, an anal fissure, rectal bleeding or pain, and check with a clinician if these persist. Stop if you feel sharp pain or notice bleeding.

When should you size up?

Move to the next size only when your current plug goes in easily, feels comfortable for a full session and no longer feels very full. Increase the diameter in small steps, around a quarter to half an inch at a time, rather than jumping sizes. Many people are perfectly happy staying with a small plug forever; bigger isn't the goal, comfort and pleasure are.

Plug or prostate massager?

A plug is about fullness and stays still; a prostate massager is curved to press on the prostate and usually vibrates. People with a prostate often enjoy both. If prostate pleasure is your goal, read our guide to the best prostate massagers for beginners.

Our picks

  1. Best first metal plug: Booty Sparks Black Rose Small.
  2. Best glass: Glas Rosebud.
  3. Best vibrating: Lovense Hush 2.

Browse more in our anal toys collection. Every order ships in a plain box with a neutral billing name.

Frequently asked questions

What size butt plug should a beginner use?

Start with a diameter of about 1 inch and an insertable length of 2 to 3 inches. The Booty Sparks Black Rose Small, at 2 inches insertable and 1 inch wide, is a good example.

Why does a butt plug need a flared base?

The rectum can draw objects inward. A flared base stays outside the body and prevents the plug from slipping inside, which could otherwise require medical removal. Only use toys designed for anal play.

How long can I wear a butt plug?

Start with 10 to 20 minutes and build up slowly. Many experienced users wear plugs for an hour or more. Remove it if you feel discomfort, numbness or pain.

What lube should I use with a butt plug?

Use a thick, long-lasting lube. With silicone plugs, choose water-based. With glass or metal, silicone or oil-based lube works too. Never use numbing lube.

Is it normal for a butt plug to feel uncomfortable at first?

Some discomfort at the widest point is common at first and fades as you relax. Sharp pain is not normal, so stop and try again another time with more lube and more warm-up.

Glass, metal or silicone: which is best?

All are good when well made. Silicone is soft and comes in vibrating models. Glass is very smooth and easy to insert. Metal is weighted and great for temperature play. Choose based on the feel you want.

More Anal Play questions in the Help Center

Browse more anal toys, all shipped in a plain box with discreet billing.

Shop the story

All anal toys

Keep reading

Your wishlist

Share this piece

Design Lab

Starting look
Colors

Fonts
Shape
Buttons
Shadows
Cards
Labels
Motion
Mode

Saved on this device only. Send the copied settings to your developer to make a look permanent.