Short answer
It shouldn't. With plenty of lube, relaxation and a slow pace, it should feel comfortable. Stop if you feel pain, and never use numbing lubes, which mask warning signs.
Read the full guideBest prostate massagers for beginnersCurious about prostate play? Learn how prostate massagers work, what makes one beginner-friendly, and our picks from Lovense, Arcwave and Satisfyer. Updated November 20, 2026 · All questions