Key takeaways
- Silicone is non-porous and cleans completely; TPE has tiny pores.
- Platinum-cure is the premium grade of silicone; most good silicone toys simply say 100% silicone.
- TPE feels softer and more skin-like, often at a lower price.
- Use water-based lube with both; silicone lube can damage silicone toys.
- Dual-density designs give a realistic soft outside and firm core in either material.
Silicone dildos are non-porous, so they clean completely, last for years and are the most body-safe choice; platinum-cure silicone is the premium grade. TPE dildos are softer and more lifelike and cost less, but they are slightly porous, so they need careful cleaning, water-based lube and a condom if shared.
Why material matters more than shape
When you choose a dildo, it's tempting to focus on size, shape and color. But the material decides how safe it is, how it feels, how you clean it and how long it lasts. The two materials you'll see most are silicone and TPE (thermoplastic elastomer, which also appears as TPR or brand names like ULTRASKYN). Here's how they compare.
How we compare: we haven't lab-tested these products. Measurements and materials come from the manufacturers' published specifications, and prices on product pages update live.
Silicone vs TPE at a glance
| Silicone | TPE / TPR | |
|---|---|---|
| Porous? | No: cleans completely | Slightly porous |
| Feel | Smooth, silky; firm to soft | Very soft, skin-like |
| Lube | Water-based only | Water-based only |
| Cleaning | Soap and water; many can be boiled (no motor) | Soap and water; never boil |
| Sharing | Safe after thorough cleaning | Use a condom |
| Lifespan | Years | Shorter; can wear or tear |
| Price | Higher | Lower |
Understanding silicone grades
"Silicone" covers a range of quality. Platinum-cure silicone is made with a platinum catalyst and is regarded as the premium grade: very stable, odor-free and long-lasting. Most reputable toys are labeled "100% silicone" or name their own premium silicone. Brands also use terms like liquid silicone, which is silicone molded from a liquid for a smooth, seamless finish. Be wary of vague labels such as "silicone blend" or "sil-a-gel," which can hide cheaper mixed materials.
Silicone picks
- Tantus Mark O2: an average-size, harness-compatible dildo in Tantus' Ultra Premium 100% Silicone, with a soft outer layer, a dense core, a slight curve for the G-spot and a thicker base for harness stability.
- SHAFT Model J: dual-layer Flexskin liquid silicone with a soft, silky outside and firm core; 5.8 inches insertable and 1.44 inches wide, with a harness-compatible suction cup.
- Evolved Real Supple Silicone Poseable: squishy liquid silicone with an inner armature you can bend and fix; 6 inches insertable, 1.52 inches wide, waterproof, with a five-year warranty.
- Simply Sweet Strawberry Sweet Cream: premium silicone with a textured shaft, 6.8 inches insertable, 1 to 2.2 inches in diameter, suction base and harness compatible.
TPE picks (with care)
- Get Lucky Mr. Lavender: dual-layer sliding skin with a soft outside and firm center, phthalate- and latex-free, with a suction base for hands-free or harness play.
- Evolved Real Supple Poseable 9.5": squishy TPE with a poseable inner steel rod; 7 inches insertable, 1.79 inches wide, waterproof, with a five-year warranty.
- Signature Cocks ULTRASKYN: Doc Johnson's ULTRASKYN material, which warms to body temperature, with a removable Vac-U-Lock suction cup.
Which should you choose?
- Choose silicone if you want the most hygienic, longest-lasting toy, plan to share it, or want to sanitize it by boiling.
- Choose TPE if you want the softest, most lifelike feel on a budget and are happy to clean it carefully.
- Want both realism and safety? Choose dual-density silicone, like the Tantus Mark or SHAFT models.
How to care for each
Silicone
Wash with warm water and mild soap or toy cleaner after every use. Motor-free 100% silicone toys can usually be boiled for a few minutes or washed on a dishwasher's top rack; check the instructions. Use water-based lube only, and store away from other silicone toys if the maker recommends it.
TPE
Wash thoroughly with warm water and mild soap after every use, then pat dry and let it air-dry completely; trapped moisture is the enemy of porous materials. A light dusting of cornstarch can keep the surface from getting tacky. Store it separately, since TPE can react with other soft materials, and use a condom if you share it.
How to spot a poor-quality toy
- A strong chemical smell often means PVC with softeners.
- An oily or sticky surface on a new toy is a warning sign.
- Vague material labels are a red flag; look for "100% silicone" or a named material.
Read our body-safe material standards for how we label every product.
The verdict
Silicone is the safest, longest-lasting choice and worth the extra cost for most people; TPE is a great budget option for realism if you're diligent about cleaning. For sizing help, see the best suction cup and beginner dildos, our dildo size and shape guide and the silicone dildo picks.
Frequently asked questions
Is TPE body-safe?
TPE is generally phthalate-free, but it is slightly porous, so it can hold bacteria if not cleaned well. Wash it after every use with warm water and mild soap, dry it completely, use water-based lube, and use a condom over it if you share it.
What is platinum silicone?
Platinum-cure silicone is made using a platinum catalyst. It is considered the premium grade of silicone and is very stable. Most quality toys are labeled simply as 100% silicone; look for that wording rather than vague terms like silicone blend.
Can you boil a silicone dildo?
Many 100% silicone dildos without motors can be boiled briefly to sanitize them. Never boil TPE, vibrating toys or anything with electronics, and check the product instructions first.
Which feels more realistic, silicone or TPE?
TPE is usually softer and more skin-like. Dual-density silicone, which has a soft outer layer over a firmer core, closes much of that gap while staying non-porous.
What lube should I use with a silicone dildo?
Water-based lube. Silicone lube can bond with silicone toys and make the surface gummy over time.
Browse more dildos, all shipped in a plain box with discreet billing.














